NYC’s Upscale Mediterranean Dining: Top Choices

New York City, known for its diverse culinary scene, offers a lavish dining experience for those seeking the flavors of the Mediterranean. With a blend of rich traditions and innovative twists, upscale Mediterranean restaurants in the city are setting a new standard in fine dining. In this guide, we’ll embark on a gastronomic journey through the top choices for upscale Mediterranean dining in the heart of NYC.

The Appeal of Mediterranean Cuisine

Mediterranean cuisine is celebrated for its rich flavors, fresh ingredients, and a unique blend of culinary traditions from countries bordering the Mediterranean Sea. From the robust spices of Morocco to the simplicity of Greek cuisine, it’s a journey that tantalizes the taste buds. The Mediterranean diet’s focus on olive oil, herbs, vegetables, and lean proteins has earned it a reputation for being both delicious and healthy.

Top Choices for Upscale Mediterranean Dining

When it comes to upscale Mediterranean dining, NYC has no shortage of exceptional restaurants. Let’s delve into some of the top choices that offer a luxurious experience:

1. The Mediterranean Pearl: Oceana

Located in Midtown Manhattan, Oceana offers a sumptuous blend of Mediterranean flavors with a focus on seafood. Their signature dish, the Mediterranean Seafood Platter, is a feast for the senses.

2. Coastal Elegance: Estiatorio Milos

Situated in the heart of Manhattan, Estiatorio Milos is renowned for its fresh Greek seafood. The elegant white decor and the famous Milos Special make it a must-visit.

3. Delights of the Aegean: Avra Madison Estiatorio

Avra Madison Estiatorio, on the Upper East Side, offers a taste of the Aegean. The whole grilled fish and the restaurant’s vibrant atmosphere are unforgettable.

4. Mediterranean Fusion: Ilili

Ilili in Flatiron combines traditional Mediterranean flavors with a modern twist. Don’t miss their lamb shawarma and creative cocktails.

5. Exquisite Lebanese: Shahrzad

Shahrzad, located in Brooklyn, brings the flavors of Lebanon to NYC. Their mezze platter and the ambiance are sure to transport you to the Middle East.

Signature Dishes and Culinary Excellence

These upscale Mediterranean restaurants are known for their signature dishes that showcase culinary excellence:

Mediterranean Seafood Platter at Oceana

This platter includes an array of fresh seafood, from oysters to prawns, served with a variety of Mediterranean-inspired sauces. It’s a seafood lover’s dream.

Milos Special at Estiatorio Milos

The Milos Special features grilled Mediterranean octopus, marinated in olive oil and herbs, creating a tender and flavorful dish that’s an instant favorite.

Whole Grilled Fish at Avra Madison Estiatorio

At Avra, the whole grilled fish, seasoned with olive oil and herbs, is a classic Mediterranean delight. The presentation is as stunning as the taste.

Lamb Shawarma at Ilili

Ilili’s lamb shawarma is a fusion masterpiece. Tender lamb is marinated in Mediterranean spices and served with fresh pita and tahini.

Mezze Platter at Shahrzad

Shahrzad’s mezze platter includes a delectable selection of Middle Eastern appetizers, from hummus and baba ghanoush to grape leaves and falafel.

Beyond the Plate: Mediterranean Dining Experience

Upscale Mediterranean restaurants offer more than just exceptional food; they provide an immersive dining experience. From the moment you step in, you’ll be enveloped in an ambiance that transports you to the Mediterranean coast. The warm hospitality and attention to detail make these dining experiences memorable.

Health Benefits and Mediterranean Lifestyle

Beyond the exquisite flavors, Mediterranean cuisine is celebrated for its health benefits. The Mediterranean diet, with its emphasis on fresh produce, whole grains, and healthy fats, is associated with reduced risks of heart disease and improved overall well-being. Dining at upscale Mediterranean restaurants allows you to indulge in gourmet food while making a health-conscious choice.

Sustainability in Upscale Mediterranean Dining

Many upscale Mediterranean restaurants in NYC are committed to sustainability. They source local ingredients, minimize food waste, and implement eco-friendly practices. By dining at these establishments, you not only enjoy exquisite cuisine but also support a more sustainable dining industry.

Bringing Mediterranean Flavors Home

If you’re inspired by the upscale Mediterranean dining experience, you can recreate some of these exquisite dishes at home. Here’s a simple yet impressive recipe to get you started:

Recipe: Grilled Mediterranean Branzino


  • Whole Branzino fish
  • Extra-virgin olive oil
  • Fresh lemon
  • Fresh herbs (rosemary, thyme, oregano)
  • Salt and pepper to taste


  1. Clean and scale the Branzino fish, leaving it whole.
  2. Season the fish with salt, pepper, and olive oil.
  3. Stuff the cavity with fresh lemon slices and herbs.
  4. Preheat your grill to medium-high heat.
  5. Grill the fish for about 5-7 minutes per side, or until the skin is crispy and the flesh is opaque.
  6. Serve with a drizzle of extra-virgin olive oil and fresh lemon juice.


Upscale Mediterranean dining in NYC offers a journey through the Mediterranean’s finest flavors, culture, and traditions. From the coastal elegance of Estiatorio Milos to the fusion creativity of Ilili, these restaurants showcase the culinary excellence of the Mediterranean region. Whether you’re a seasoned food enthusiast or a curious diner, the upscale Mediterranean dining scene in NYC promises an unforgettable experience.

FAQs About Upscale Mediterranean Dining in NYC

  1. Are reservations recommended for upscale Mediterranean restaurants in NYC?Yes, reservations are highly recommended, especially for popular upscale Mediterranean restaurants. It ensures you secure a table, especially during peak dining hours.
  2. Do upscale Mediterranean restaurants in NYC offer vegetarian and vegan options?Most upscale Mediterranean restaurants in NYC offer a range of vegetarian and vegan dishes, making them suitable for diverse dietary preferences.
  3. What should I wear to upscale Mediterranean restaurants in NYC?Dress codes may vary, but generally, upscale Mediterranean restaurants have a smart-casual dress code. It’s a good idea to check with the restaurant in advance.
  4. Is the seafood in upscale Mediterranean restaurants sustainably sourced?Many upscale Mediterranean restaurants in NYC prioritize sustainability and source seafood responsibly. They often highlight their sourcing practices on their menus or websites.
  5. Are children welcome at upscale Mediterranean restaurants?While upscale restaurants may have a more formal atmosphere, children are usually welcome. It’s a good idea to inquire about high chairs or kids’ menus when making reservations.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *