10 Best Italian Restaurants in New York

New York City is a melting pot of cultures, and its Italian culinary scene is nothing short of spectacular. From classic red-sauce joints to modern interpretations of Italian cuisine, there’s something for every palate. Whether you’re a local looking for your new favorite spot or a visitor wanting to savor the best Italian food the city has to offer, read on to discover the top 10 Italian restaurants in New York.

Carbone: A Taste of Old New York

When you step into Carbone, you’re instantly transported to the golden era of Italian-American dining. This Greenwich Village gem is renowned for its classic dishes, impeccable service, and a vintage ambiance that harks back to the mid-20th century.

L’Artusi: Modern Italian Elegance

For a more contemporary Italian experience, L’Artusi in the West Village is a must-visit. With its sleek design and innovative cuisine, it’s a favorite among those seeking modern Italian elegance.

Marea: Seafood Sensations

Located in Central Park South, Marea takes Italian seafood to new heights. Their crudo and pasta dishes are legendary, and the stunning views of Central Park add to the allure.

Roberta’s: Brooklyn’s Pizza Gem

Pizza aficionados can’t miss Roberta’s in Brooklyn. This hip pizzeria offers wood-fired pies that have earned it a cult following among locals and visitors alike.

Scampi: The Essence of Italian Simplicity

Scampi, nestled in the Flatiron District, focuses on simplicity and quality. Their commitment to fresh ingredients shines through in every dish, making it a top choice for Italian purists.

Don Angie: Fusion at its Finest

Don Angie in the West Village is where traditional Italian meets inventive fusion. The inventive menu features dishes like lasagna for two and stuffed garlic flatbread, perfect for sharing.

Frankies 457 Spuntino: Cozy Italian Comfort

Frankies 457 Spuntino in Carroll Gardens offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. Their homemade pastas and classic Italian flavors make it a beloved neighborhood gem.

Il Buco: A Mediterranean Hideaway

Il Buco, located in NoHo, transports diners to a Mediterranean hideaway with its rustic d├ęcor and artisanal cuisine. Their emphasis on sourcing local and sustainable ingredients sets them apart.

L’Amico: A Chef-Driven Experience

L’Amico, adjacent to Herald Square, offers a chef-driven Italian dining experience. The wood-fired oven and grill produce exceptional flavors in dishes like their roasted chicken.


From the nostalgic charm of Carbone to the modern elegance of L’Artusi and the inventive fusion at Don Angie, New York City’s Italian restaurant scene has something for everyone. These top 10 Italian restaurants showcase the city’s diverse culinary landscape, ensuring that your Italian dining experience in the Big Apple will be nothing short of memorable.


  1. What is the best time to visit these restaurants to avoid long wait times?
    • It’s advisable to make reservations in advance, especially for popular spots like Carbone and L’Artusi, to ensure a seamless dining experience.
  2. Are these restaurants suitable for vegetarian or vegan diners?
    • While some of these restaurants offer vegetarian and vegan options, it’s a good idea to check their menus or call ahead to inquire about specific dietary needs.
  3. Do any of these restaurants offer outdoor seating?
    • Many of these restaurants have outdoor seating options, providing a delightful al fresco dining experience, weather permitting.
  4. What is the average price range for a meal at these restaurants?
    • Prices vary by restaurant and the number of courses you choose, but you can expect to pay anywhere from $50 to $150 per person, excluding beverages.
  5. Can you recommend any of these restaurants for a special occasion or romantic dinner?
    • Marea and Il Buco are excellent choices for special occasions, with their elegant settings and exceptional cuisine.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *